Panelists talk strategy for community editorials

Senior, The George Washington University

Panelists at Don't Call it UGC

Robin Sloan of Twitter introduces the panelists, from left to right: Laura Brunow Miner of Pictory, and Alexis Madrigal and Sarah Rich, both of Longshot Magazine. Photo by Heather Hodder

At “Don’t Call it UGC,” panelists shared advice for journalists who seek to produce quality work through crowdsourcing.

Laura Brunow Miner, founder of Pictorymag and the quickly expanding Phootcamp, joined Alexis Madrigal and Sarah Rich, co-founders of
Longshot Magazine, to talk strategy for how their projects have been able to publish high quality content from online submissions.

“Finesse, hard work and respect are the three words to keep in mind and walk away with from this panel,” said Robin Sloan, who works on media partnerships at Twitter. “They’re not tech words but craft words. Crowdsourcing is a skill you can learn.”

Panelists asserted that User Generated Content (UGC) is misleading because it implies inferior quality work; content for Longshot and Pictory is carefully edited and fact-checked similar to traditional publications. Instead, panelists preferred the term “community editorials” to convey the craftsmanship they say is innate within crowdsourcing.

“With UGC more often there’s terror about opening the floodgates to send a lot of crap in. What we’re doing is different, our content comes through a very fine filter,” said Sarah Rich, former senior editor for Dwell Magazine.

Longshot is a magazine that is created over only 48 hours, with the theme announced right before the clock starts ticking. Submissions are accepted only within the first 24 hours, and in the next 24 the magazine is edited, compiled and made available for purchase online. The contributors are paid, but through “socialism” and “meritocracy” as explained by Longshot’s website.

One-third of the profits from the first 48 days of the magazine’s sale are divided evenly among contributors and staff. However contributors and staff vote on all of the published content, and the contributor whose piece comes in first gets the second third of profits. The remaining third of the profits goes toward future publication efforts.

For the majority of the contributions to the magazine, it’s not big bucks. For the first issue, the average contributor was paid $8.93, Rich said.

With little compensation, and none at all for contributors to Pictory, all of the panelists agreed that there is something stronger behind community motivation.

“It gives people exposure, and a chance to vent emotionally. If you need convincing, look at Post Secret …people find it cathartic,” Brunow Miner said. Her site pictorymag.com displays weekly photo showcases connected by a theme. Anyone from around the world can submit a photo along with a caption, and photos are chosen based on how the theme was interpreted. “I look for photos that tell a story,” Brunow Miner said.

Of course there are difficulties in producing community editorials, such as finding a way to connect a seemingly disjointed staff of strangers.

“Voice is wrapped up in a lot of ways, and there is often assumption you sacrifice voice [through crowdsourcing]. How do you make sure voice is behind all of it?” Sloan asked.

“A great edit is the secret to community editorials,” said Brunow Miner ” I do line edits–highlighting words that I think are important helps it become cohesive–and I e-mail them back to my contributors for changes.”

Editors show respect for contributors’ work so that contributors will submit again. Pictory gains respect from contributors by letting them check edits before publication, and Longshot magazine instructs those whose submissions aren’t chosen to publish them on their own blogs, and then Longshot usually links to them.

All of the panelists have a strong presence on Twitter, where much marketing takes place. You can follow them at @pictory or @longshotmag.

Share the digital evolution:

  • Print
  • email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • FriendFeed
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • Posterous
  • StumbleUpon
  • Tumblr
  • yanggang023

    Wherever your home is globally, almost everyone must have house furniture! House furniture discusses Jacksonville Jaguars Jersey a number of goods plus distinctive versions and even capacities. Within the last small amount of many decades China’s current economic climate contains looked at unparalleled improvement and even one of the more good markets was large wicker house furniture. You would certainly look Official Carolina Panthers Jerseys into Japan large wicker house furniture in today’s guide.
    Record in Japan Large Wicker House furniture
    A number of reasons contain provided with the achieving success in China’s large wicker furnitureindustry, additionally, the area Official Detroit Lions Jerseys is without a doubt swift getting to Official Atlanta Falcons Jerseys be one of the more leading house furniture exporters globally.
    An array of economical struggle bills, a major individual advertise and even instantly declining upload contract price quotes contains required which will large numbers of imported companies are demonstrating to any on Japan large Jacksonville Jaguars Jersey wicker house furniture.
    In recent times you can get many hundreds of house furniture crops put together spanning Japan, a number Joakim Noah Jersey of managed as a result of sizeable transnational house furniture suppliers plus some B2B Networks in wholsale house furniture creep into vision, likeWickerchina, B&Q, IKEA.
    Advantage of Japan Large Wicker House furniture
    There’s a lot of health benefits to purchasing house furniture as a result of Japan wicker wholesalers. The best edge is without a doubt the variety of possible choices you have got. Japan belongs to the main states globally and even ones own development trade contains quoted with the thriving depend on for pick as a result of the nation’s huge importers. You don’t have a genuine pattern and high-quality in house furniture marketed because of Japan wholesalers simply because a whole lot of manufacturing supplies different things. So in cases where you need house furniture you don’t have more desirable location to start looking than only a Japan wholesaler!
    The advantage of opting for to own wicker house furniture on a Japan wholesaler is definitely the cost you. Not very many states will be able to sector and tory burch flip flops sale can cost you which will Japan wholesalers offers ones own house furniture designed for based on upload data plans often bringing down, they are really wholesale prada sunglasses getting to be possibly even more inexpensive to own.
    Japan contains easy access to help you localized unprocessed trash, and even in every issues some people shouldn’t transfer items as a result of several other states. It will aid to create formation bills downward and even a lot Official Cleveland Browns Jerseys of these reductions can be passed on you.

  • oakley sunglasses

     discount oakley sunglasses shop is a professional website to provide cheap oakley sunglasses shopping, there oakley sunglasses cheap, oakley sunglasses discount, good service is our only belief is to choose oakley sunglasses choose our beautiful, happy life of self-confidence from the sun began

  • http://www.coachhandbag-onsale.com/ coach chelsea collection

    I like levels that don’t go
    on too much.

  • http://www.prlog.org/11289974-phone-number-lookup-verizon-phone-number-reverse-lookup-to-get-information-you-need-quickly.html phone number lookup

    Looks like things went great

  • longchamp sale

    Longchamp Bags characteristics appealing and entertaining slogans in their like this style worn by Madonna immediately gives each upper-class modern look.Longchamp Le Pliage is it the most affordable, many consumers can afford a series.  Longchamp Sale can be quite a brand of luxury and luxury. 

    Longchamp Le Pliage the elements is very simple, nylon body of the handle and cover the surface of the cortex, matched with a variety of colors.You will always be Longchamp Bags heroine.Longchamp Sale you can not refuse the temptation.

  • http://www.reversephonelookupsearch.com/ phone number lookup

    How much of an unique article, keep on posting better half

  • http://www.cellphonelookuped.com/ cell phone directory

    Wonderful web site. Plenty of helpful information here. I’m sending it to some friends ans also sharing in delicious. And of course, thank you for your effort!

  • http://paydayloans01.info/ payday loans

    Have you tried twitterfeed on your blog, i think it would be cool.

  • http://reversecellphonelookup.me/ reverse cell phone lookup

    Hi there, have you ever before thought about to create regarding 

  • http://www.thoughts.com/cellphonenumberlookup/cell-phone-number-lookup-find-out-their-name-and-address cell phone number lookup

    Only desire to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is only first-class and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the gratifying work.

  • http://www.ourmidland.com/voices/community/article_3abc5302-931f-11e1-ac26-8f9c10b62f96.html cell phone lookup

    Magnificent site. Plenty of helpful info here. I am sending it to several pals ans also sharing in delicious. And certainly, thanks on your sweat!

blog comments powered by Disqus